Regards,
N
Awareness of financial issues, especially on the personal front is minimal even among highly educated professionals, including quite a few "Finance Professionals". This blog is intended to be of some value addition to anyone who cares about his/her personal finance. The focus will be on the Indian situation, though the principles will be applicable the world over..... (Please read the disclaimer at the bottom of this page without fail)
Buy-and-hold is far from dead but perhaps it has been misunderstood. As with many other investment topics, it is instructive to look to Warren Buffett's example.
Perhaps no other investor personifies buy-and-hold more than Buffett, who has stated that his preferred holding period is forever. But as with all things Buffett, this folksy tidbit is not his final word on this topic. When it comes to the Oracle of Omaha, we need to observe Buffett's actions as well as his words and for that, we go back to Buffett's early days running his hedge fund.
In letters to his partners, Buffett laid out three investment categories (later expanded to four): generals, workouts and controls. The generals were the buy-and-hold portion of his portfolio and usually comprised the largest portion of his holdings. These were value stocks he bought but was unable to predict when he would realize the expected gains. In fact, he warned that these stocks could suffer long periods of underperformance. The controls were similarly undervalued companies but where Buffett could take an activist (or controlling) role which could provide an impetus for realizing the value in these positions. Both of these categories could be labelled as buy-and-hold strategies.
The workouts, by contrast, were short-term investments with defined timelines and catalysts for validating the investment thesis. By their nature, these were not buy-and-hold investments yet they were an integral part of his early investment strategy. It is important to remember that Buffett was running a hedge fund and unlike today's charlatans, refused to be paid unless he made money for his partners. This provision also ensured he was very motivated to deliver positive annual returns. The workouts segment was instrumental in providing near-term, relatively dependable returns to balance out the buy-and-hold portion of the fund's holdings.
My take:
This had been a much-debated topic for discussion as well as introspection.
VIEWS OF Mr. NMERITS OF BUY-AND-HOLDI was thoroughly convinced about the need to "Buy & Hold". It is quite apparent that it generates untold of long-term wealth. All of us have our own favourite examples. Mine is TITAN INDUSTRIES. A couple of decades back - perhaps around the time when Titan was just listed, I was a newbie to the stock market.I'd identified it as a good pick, and picked up a then "huge" quantity for me - 200 shares at Rs. 30/=. As I'd predicted to myself, over the next few months, it moved from strength to strength, and, within 5-6 months, crossed Rs. 60/=.I was thrilled. I'd doubled my money in less than a year.And, I sold all my Titan. Doubled my money in less than a year. The rest, as they say, is history.In due course of time, I learnt one of my most valuable lessons.
I've certainly not come to any conclusions about dumping "Buy & Hold".
However, it is absolutely imperative that we must not be wedded to the "Buy & Hold" strategy. Or else, we would have got sub-optimal returns by holding on to our shares (like most of us did) between November 2007 and February 2008.Each of us ought to identify our own personal style of investing which works best for us.I personally prefer to classify stocks into the following categories:
STEADY BLUE CHIPS - A good example would be a scrip like HDFC Bank - Always looks expensive on PE terms. A couple of quarters after you refrain from buying, if you take a look at it, it would have gone up even further, and will still look expensive. But, surprisingly, the old price at which you originally refrained from buying will now appear to be an attractive price based on the current earnings. The only problem - You'll never be able to catch it at price levels acceptable to you. With such stocks, there are only two alternatives - either buy with either blind faith or conviction and hold forever - or forget about holding them at any point of time! UNSTEADY BLUE CHIPS - A good example would be TISCO - Thanks to the commodity cycle (or whatever) it gyrates wildly, but nobody ever disputes about whether it is a blue chip. After all, it belongs to the house of TATAs & it has been around for more years than most of the investors' parents have been around on this planet. With such stocks, try and identify good levels to get in and to partly get out, and keep accumulating ever-increasing quantities. On those rare occasions when you end up buying such shares at the equivalent of January 2008, you can still mentally afford to keep them for good, as part of your long-term portfolio. MOMEMTUM BOYS - An excellent example would be Aban Offshore - Of course, the momentum boys keep changing in every cycle of 4-5 years. In some yester years a Silverline or Pentamedia or NEPC could have been momentum boys. These scrips gyrate without any rhyme or reason - and sometimes with reason. In percentage terms, they move around very violently. My strategy for such stocks is to allocate relatively minor sums of money, identify good entry / exit levels, keep buying and selling quickly, and maintain very strict stop losses. The last part about strict stop losses is the most important part, but has been perennially difficult for me. Reason - Behavioural Finance fundas (either listen to people like Parag Parikh to know more or wait for a future post on the subject of Behavioural Finance) OVER THE HILL GRANDPAS - These are the stocks that were, once upon a time, great companies. Perhaps were part of the SENSEX in yester-years. And belong to very reputed business houses - with promoters who are typically part of the "Old Rich". These companies may or may not recover their old glory ever again. However, the probability of their disappearing altogether is quite low. And, surprisingly, every couple of years, they end up quoting at sub-par levels (like Rs. 8-10 for a Rs. 10/= share), and in every couple of years, they also reach modest levels (of Rs. 20-30 for a Rs. 10/= share, for instance). Examples of such stocks would include companies like Hindustan Motors, SPIC. I'll be willing to have greater confidence on these stocks than the momentum boys. Hence my allocation could be slightly more. However, I'll strictly look at them as mid-term trading ploys with strict stop losses. Buy when they go to sufficiently low levels and get out when you've doubled your money a few weeks / months or a couple of years later. It is bound to happen. But, please don't ask me why or how - I have no reason to proffer!Happy investing!Regards,N
VIEWS OF Mr. NMAKING HAY WHILE THE SUN SHINES
I was equally convinced about the wild swings of the "Manic-Depressive" "Mr. Market" - After all, the indices keep going up and down all the time, taking all kinds of good, bad, ugly and crooked stocks along with it.An interesting way to make money would be to keep "trading" by buying 2-5 times a year and selling 2-5 times a year the very same stock. This would also fetch lots of money, provided, of course, you choose the right stocks.Good examples of pretty high quality companies which keep going up and down in 2-3 year cycles would include TISCO, ICICI Bank, etc.If only we learn to use the ups and downs, we can freak out with many of these stocks. I did that with a couple of stocks, and benefitted significantly.In due course of time, I learnt another of my most valuable lessons.
An Interesting Fact after the sharp move of September 13th
Posted by: "GV"
Mon Sep 13, 2010 10:42 pm (PDT)
Yesterday when nifty broke out sharply by about 2.13 % ;
- there were only 26 stocks among nifty category which outperformed the
index and 76 that under performed.
- and among a-z category, there were just 216 stocks that out performed and
as many as 1101 stocks which under performed.
*gv*
Investors get perturbed when the markets are not moving up in a sustained manner. And rightly so, because most investors have a mindset of buy and hold. And when the markets frequently change their direction, investors find it difficult to cope with such volatility.Changed environment calls for a change in the strategy we deploy to tackle the markets. Just as you adopt different strategies to face fast bowlers and spinners and play the ball on its merits similarly the strategies need to change to play different market condition.The volatility could be a blessing in disguise, if you can acclimatize yourself with it.1.Take your ones and twosIn a volatile market you should learn to take small gains and losses. Instead of yearning for a large gain, hitting a six in cricket parlance, you should settle for smaller gains and take them as they come.A stock may not give you a 20% return in one go but may give you 25% returns in trenches. Sounds impossible? Lets see.We chose Tata Steel and studied how it behaved during the Months of April and May. The stock gave 5 upswings of 5% or more and 5 down swings of 5% or more during the period. So whether you are a bull or a bear, you got ample opportunities.The Tata Steel swings were larger than 5%. The 5% was only a filter mark. The upswings were to the tune of 18, 5, 10, 8 and 7% respectively. Even if you could catch any one of them and rode only 5%, it would have been a good return to post.On the downside, the swings were 9, 21, 20,10 and 6%. The magnitude of these downswings was larger than those of the upswings.The best part of a volatile market is that you get to buy the same stock again and again at the same level or lower. The chances are that if you get this act once right, subsequent opportunities will be easier to spot and ride.2.Create some cashIf you are sitting on a pile of cash, you will see the falling market as an opportunity to buy. But if you are fully invested you will be fearful. In that fear, you are likely to sell some of the stocks at a loss.On a day like this, when the markets tumble sharply, the one with cash will confidently buy where as some one who is fully invested may end up selling his stocks at a loss.I have always thought that sitting on a 20-30% cash is a good idea. The very fact that you have to maintain this kind of cash will make your investment decisions well thought out. You will research and then buy and that too when the valuations are compulsive.And on a day when the markets open down sharply, this cash can be put to good use. The stocks that you buy with this cash will have to sell in a disciplined manner. The cash so generated will be used only when the markets tumble further or a really good investment opportunity is spotted.
If you are fully invested, sell a part of your stocks when the markets move north. Selling and creating cash at leisure and when the markets move up is better than selling in panic. However, if you realize that the recent investment you made is not a sound decision, selling that stock at a loss is not bad idea for cash generation.3.Buy PutsBuying a Put in the stocks concerned protects your portfolio. Protection comes at a cost. In the beginning of the month, the costs are pretty high. So in order to reduce your protection cost, you may perhaps want to trade off writing a lower Put. Your portfolio is protected till the strike price for which you write or sell a Put. When you do such a thing, it is called constructing a Bear Spread.4.Write higher CallsWhen stocks are tumbling and you are not buying Puts, it may worthwhile to write a higher call for the stocks that you have. If the markets tumble you will get to keep the premium you earn. To that extent you are compensated. Should the markets reverse and move higher, what you do next will be a function what is your trading profit or loss in the call written. If the call is going in your favor, cover it. But if you are making a trading loss, don't book it. Hold your position till settlement. On that day, if the call premium is still higher than your buying cost, let it lapse and sell your existing stock (for which the Call was written) in the last 10 minutes of trade in the cash market.5.Keep your stop losses tightWhen you are playing for smaller profits, it is advisable to keep your losses even smaller. So keep tight stop losses. Decide on your stop loss before entering the trade and make it a trailing one as the market moves your way. Even in Puts and Call options stop losses can be kept.6.Be Nimble footedExpecting that the markets will tank, you by puts in the Nifty. And after going your way for some time, the market changes direction. While you have the choice of selling your Put option, you may consider buying a Nifty Future to make the best use of the Put that is already bought. If the markets recover to the level where you bought the Put, your buying of the Nifty future would have been justified.There are further games you can play with this Put you had bought. If you think the Nifty is likely to lose momentum, book profits in the Nifty, still holding on to your put. This gives you another opportunity to enter the Nifty Futures again at lower levels. You can repeat this several times in a week.The adept amongst you would have understood that with the protection of Put to support you get the full advantage of the range of futures movement. If the Nifty moves in a range of 50 points, you get the full advantage of trading in the Nifty. Where as trading in the option alone would give you only half the range.Similarly, when the Nifty reaches the upper range of the range, buying a Call and then shorting the Nifty Futures and covering at lower levels will be helpful. Rinse and repeat as many times as you want, till the option you have bought remains relevant.7.Buy in small quantitiesIf you hate trading and are not the like who will settle for smaller profits, the least you can do is, defer your buying over three stages. You may buy a third quantity of your researched share at the first go. The next third can be bought 5% or 10% lower depending on the volatility of the stock and the balance quantity still after another same percentage gap.You may repent buying only a third of your desired quantity if the stock surges after your buying. In such a case, you would probably end up with notional loss, for the quantity you never bought. But if the market does go down, you will appreciate your foresight.All said an done, if you plan your trading and investing assuming that the volatility will continue, you are likely to land on your feet. As you go through this experience, keeping your cool, you will begin to appreciate the opportunities volatility offers and may in fact begin to love it.And in a few months you will also get to trade in Volatility Index (VIX) itself. So treat the current volatility as a practice session to master VIX trading.Sincerely,HDFC Securities Limited
Power of Trading
Many people misunderstand the concept of
Both the above are completely wrong. I'll explain in greater detail in later posts.
In this post, I'm going to share with you hypothetical figures of the difference that one can make with
Take a look at this table:
| Power of Trading, rather than holding long-term! Wonder if it is feasible??? | Initial Amount Invested | Annual Return | No. of Years | Final Value of Investment | |
| | | | | | |
| | Impact of buying shares at just 3% lower cost and trading periodically so as to get just a 2% additional return annually | 97,000 | 1.20 | 10 | 600,598 |
| | 100,000 | 1.18 | 10 | 523,384 | |
| | | | | | |
| | 97,000 | 1.14 | 10 | 359,600 | |
| | 100,000 | 1.12 | 10 | 310,585 |
You'll realise something that ought to be obvious:
Think about it!
And Act!
Regards,
N
Of Pins & Bubbles
A pin lies in wait for every bubble and when the two eventually meet, a new wave of investors learns some very old lessons. - Warren Buffett
Considering the credentials of the Guru from Omaha, I can't take the chance of disagreeing with the sage all the time.
As enough number of investment gurus have pointed out, bubbles will keep getting formed as long as naive investors are floating around on this planet.
As long as bubbles are in existence, pins will keep searching for them.
On every such occasion when the two meet (I mean the pin and the bubble), inevitably the bubble will burst.
The whole process goes on somewhat along the lines suggested below:
Moral of the story:
Happy investing!
Regards,
N
World Thrift Day - Why ALL of us Ought to invest in Equity
Dear Friends,
Wishing you all a very happy "WORLD THRIFT DAY" - Apparently, it is celebrated on October 30th!
To me, every day is a Thrift Day.
On this occasion, I'd like to make a preposterous suggestion: All of us MUST invest in Equity (either directly or through mutual funds - at least through Nifty BEES). Many may be aghast at this suggestion, saying that Equity is not appropriate for anyone who can't afford to take a risk.
However, I differ.
Take a look at the following table:
| Reason as to why you must remain exposed to Equity! | Initial Amount Invested | Annual Return | No. of Years | Final Value of Investment |
| Even if the initial investment is half, if annual returns are much better, the final value will be much bigger over a long period of time. Moral of the story: Invest at least part of the amount in Equity to ensure higher returns over a period of time. | 50,000 | 1.14 | 10 | 185,361 |
| 100,000 | 1.08 | 10 | 215,892 | |
| 50,000 | 1.14 | 15 | 356,897 | |
| 100,000 | 1.08 | 15 | 317,217 | |
| 50,000 | 1.14 | 20 | 687,174 | |
| 100,000 | 1.08 | 20 | 466,096 |
You'll notice that:
You'll further notice that beyond 15 years, the guy who initially invested just half the sum initially actually outperforms the other guy.
That's the power of a combination of:
If the above results are achieved with just a one-time investment, just imagine what you can achieve with a recurring investment in Equity with a good chunk of your disposable surplus savings!
Happy investing. May all of you grow immensely rich and wealthy beyond your wildest dreams!
Regards,
N